rainwaterspark: Image of Link at the Earth Temple in Skyward Sword (legend of zelda skyward sword earth temp)
[personal profile] rainwaterspark
Whiteout by Elyse Springer
(edited 4/4/2017 for additional thoughts)

So. I am a sucker for amnesia stories. They're my kryptonite. The fastest way to get me to read a book is to say the main character has amnesia.

I enjoyed the twist of the book. It's rare that I'm surprised by a twist and it used the amnesia in an interesting way, so that was cool.

Other than that, though...the book was nice, but very romance-trope-y. Too much so for my tastes. The second half of the book was boringly predictable, everything wraps up very neatly, and so on.

I also felt that the writing didn't wring out the emotional responses enough in certain places, and Noah felt way younger than a 29-year-old to me. Plus, Jason didn't strike me as more than a 2-dimensional character, and because of that, I never felt really enthusiastic about Noah and Jason's relationship. There just wasn't enough closeness between them, and it felt like a large part of their relationship was built primarily on sexual attraction (which, alone, doesn't sell a romance to me).

For example, Jason makes a comment at some point along the lines that he likes the fact that Noah is distant, because it keeps Noah interesting to him. My reaction to that was "WTF?" A relationship in which the partners have to keep distant from each other to keep things exciting...doesn't strike me as a long-lasting relationship.

Also, I dunno, I feel weird about the plot in the second half of the book of Noah/Nathan trying to "win" Jason back by building a book for him, inviting him to the opening night of the musical Nathan was starring in, etc. It felt too...juvenile for two adults, one of whom is middle-aged? (This is part of what I meant when I said it felt too romance-trope-y.) I've never been super comfortable with the idea of "fighting" to win back a romantic partner, because I feel like if you really respected your partner's free will, you'd let them come to their own conclusion about whether or not to give you a second chance. And if not, oh well, breakups suck, but they're a fact of life.


Of the Abyss by Amelia Atwater-Rhodes

Ooh, it's been WAY too long since I've read a fantasy book with competent worldbuilding, and Of the Abyss really scratched that itch. Plus, I love fantasy based on early modern rather than medieval times, and that's something I never get enough of.

I don't have gushing feelings about the book, but I enjoyed it overall and I'm curious to see where the series goes next. I was particularly a fan of the relationship between Hansa and Umber—Hansa is my favorite kind of "generic do-gooder"/"how did I find myself in this situation" hero and Umber is surprisingly complex. Plus, antagonistic bickering between romantic (?) leads is always fun.

Maybe I've been reading too much romance/erotica lately, but given Hansa's initial hesitance about being in a relationship with a man, I kind of expected the book to go into more detail about how he adjusts to a sexual relationship with Umber (at least a conversation or internal monologue about it afterwards). But maybe that's just me.
This account has disabled anonymous posting.
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

Profile

rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
rainwaterspark

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 13th, 2025 08:49 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios