rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
I know that one criticism of The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild's map was that it was huge, but too empty. But honestly, I loved exploration in Breath of the Wild. Whenever I wanted to pick up a video game and do something low-key, I would open that game, look at the map, and go somewhere I hadn't been before, in search of Korok seeds or treasure chests. To me, the brilliance of that game's map design was the fact that I was almost always rewarded with Korok seeds and/or treasure chests when I ventured somewhere new. It was rewarding in a relaxed way, a very zen experience.

The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom clearly read that criticism and decided to fix it...by overloading the map with Stuff.

I already thought BotW had tons of treasure chests that could be found if you went searching, but TotK has even more. More chests, more Korok seeds, way more enemy encampments, Lightroots, caves/Bubblfrogs, Addison's signs, wells, way more armor to find and upgrade...for a completionist, the game can easily become overwhelming.

And that's what I find myself mulling over. Because I do sometimes approach TotK the same way as BotW: by opening up the map, looking for a spot I've never been to, and venturing there to find Korok seeds and treasure chests. When my goal is only exploration, it feels as zen as BotW did. But when I set out with a goal of completion, then I find myself getting frustrated with how many things there are to 100% in this game, and how hard they are to complete without a guide. (I am not anti-guide in general for video games, but for puzzle/exploration-focused games, I feel like using a guide cheapens the experience.)

I don't know, I guess I don't have an answer for myself yet? Other than it's all in my mind, lol.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
Lately, I've been seeing a lot of news in my writer circles from BIPOC authors who found rep from amazing advocates after losing their first agent, or landing book deals after long ordeals on submission, and many of them have been saying things like "dreams really do come true!"

And all I can think is...your dreams came true. But mine aren't.

There's a weird sense of shame that I feel, having been querying for 7 months without getting an offer of representation. Being rejected by the majority of agents who say they want to represent authors of color. I just feel like...why am I not enough? What is wrong with me/my books?

It would be a different story if I knew my writing wasn't skilled enough or my ideas are too niche. But they're not. Every time I pitch my books to other people (other authors and acquaintances I barely know), people always say they sound amazing. And yet I can't convince agents/editors that my stories are worth anything.

Right now, I have two agents who still have my full manuscript and seven who have my query. Aside from a few agents at those "only query one agent at a time" agencies, I've pretty much exhausted my list. I'm at this weird point at which I'm stuck in a holding pattern—I feel like there are still too many agents who have my query/manuscript for me to say I have no hope of representation, but I've also been waiting without news for months and really, really wishing I could just yeet my book at some open submission calls so I can feel like I'm *doing something*.

I'm going to try revising Novel #4 during the holidays, but I feel like I'm not even excited to query that book. Because I'll be going out to the exact same agent pool who rejected Novel #5 (which I feel like is objectively better written), so even if I get interest for Novel #4 from those people my reaction is going to be "what the hell is wrong with you??" Also, although I tend to bounce around different subgenres, my consistent "brand" so to speak is the way I approach plot, characterization, and themes, and I just feel like if you don't like how I write one novel, you will probably not like anything else I write.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
The Dark Becomes Her by Judy I. Lin

Genre: YA, horror

I may attempt to keep listening to this audiobook, but right now, it's looking like a DNF in the first half.

I'm dying for more horror based on non-Western folklore/history, because the possibilities are endless. I wanted to love this book so badly, but sadly, I'm not enjoying it much.

Judy Lin's books have always been mixed reads for me, and this one is no different. My biggest problem is with the pacing. It's, frankly, very slow. And while slow-burn horror is a thing (like Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia), what makes slow-burn horror work is the slowly creeping sense of unease and dread. This book doesn't really have that. Instead, random ghost attacks are interspersed with a pretty slice-of-life narrative about Ruby's life. There isn't a slow build/escalation as much as random acceleration and deceleration in the pacing. It feels like it took until 1/3 of the way through the book for the second act to even start. And that's just too slow to keep my attention.

Other problems I had: the horror parts did not feel atmospheric enough to me. Also, I feel like Lin's protagonists all sound almost exactly the same, and it's become rather noticeable.

What the book does nail is portraying the second-generation Chinese/Taiwanese immigrant experience, for better or for worse. Some of the things Ruby's mom says to her reminded me of what my mom said to me as a kid (like, in a mildly triggering way). But I did find myself grinning when Ruby's parents spoke Chinglish in one chapter, because that's exactly how my parents talked:

"我们next Wednesday晚上有空吗?"
"...Maybe? 我看一下schedule."


*


I've been complaining a lot about how a lot of books I've read this year have not been well written, and another consequence of that is that I can't find any comfort reads.

I used to read a lot of queer romance/queer romantasy as comfort reads. But the traditionally published queer romances I've tried are too rubbish to be comfort reads. And so I'm left in a constant state of frustration (and also rereading my own novels to scratch that romance comfort read itch).

I don't think my standards are that high? I just want some romantic tension and chemistry between the leads, so I can really root for them as a couple. Even trashy self-published Amazon romances do better than tradpubbed romantasies in this respect, because they've nailed that tension down to a science. There's something deeply comforting about the familiar rhythm of a romance novel, the waiting with anticipation for two characters who are clearly attracted to each other to get over their hang-ups and get together.

And I just don't get why that's so hard to find in tradpubbed queer romantasy. Sigh.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
I have been having an absolutely terrible time with traditionally published Chinese fantasy (by Chinese authors) this year. The only ones I’ve enjoyed were The Emperor and the Endless Palace by Justinian Huang, and The Blood Orchid by Kylie Lee Baker. Every other one I’ve read has been a one- or two-star read. :(

As an example, I recently read The Last Dragon of the East by Katrina Kwan, which I was really looking forward to, but it was just so mediocre to me. (I know people argue that BIPOC authors should be allowed to write mediocre books, but at the same time, am I not allowed to be disappointed when mediocre books are published when so many talented authors of color are languishing because they're deemed "not relatable" or "not marketable enough"?)

One of the issues I had with the book was that the Chinese fantasy elements felt so superficial. Apart from the reincarnation/red thread of fate concept, if you took out the dragons, the teahouse, and the emperor, this could have easily been a generic Western fantasy. Hell, the book even features fae beasts and will-o-the-wisps already.

I've been ruminating a lot lately on the topic of what makes Chinese fantasy "culturally Chinese" and how much that matters. To be honest, it wasn't until I started reading danmei novels that I realized fantasy novels set in China by authors in China do feel very different from fantasy novels by diaspora authors, in terms of how (fantasy) China is depicted - the cultures, the traditions, the language.

I mean, the system of pronouns and honorifics in ancient China is extremely complicated, and while I don't expect a diaspora author to necessarily know when an ancient Chinese person would refer to themselves as 本官 or 小的 or (family name) 麿 (heck, I don't necessarily know either), I think it's worth trying to convey some of the speech patterns rather than just having everyone talk like a 21st-century English-speaking American. (Personally, I love writing Chinese fantasy characters introducing themselves like "My family name is X, my given name Y" to emulate "我姓 X,名 Y".)

I can really tell now when a Chinese diaspora author is aware of Chinese folklore and cultural nuances. I had that feeling while reading Justinian Huang, Joan He, and Judy I. Lin's novels.

But I'm also personally wrestling with the fact that I don't like ideas of cultural "purity" or gatekeeping diaspora authors from writing fantasy. And I have enjoyed Chinese fantasy novels by Sue Lynn Tan, RF Kuang, and Kylie Lee Baker that feature Western values and/or storytelling traditions in certain ways.

I think it comes down to, for me, feeling like a diaspora author has done some research on ancient China, instead of just taking some superficial elements and running with their imagination of what ancient China is like (because isn't that the exact same thing white people do?).

All this is, of course, not even getting to how traditional publishing is dominated by white people who are the arbiters of what should be published even when they have no knowledge of Chinese culture or storytelling. Sigh.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
It's been 6 months since I started querying, and I haven't heard anything about my outstanding queries for what feels like forever. I feel like I've become numb to it all, although there are two agents who have my query/full who are opening back up to queries next month, so I feel like I might get responses from them soon? Maybe???

Nearly every book I've read over the past month has been, quite honestly, poorly written. I know this is a controversial opinion, but I honestly think that the reason many books haven't sold that well this year is that they're just badly written. It's usually hard to say books are "objectively" bad, but I have read so many recently published books that have:

- stiff, wooden, unrealistic dialogue
- tons of telling rather than showing (including infodumping)
- action scenes that consist of vague summaries
- POV jumps from third-person limited to omniscient within the same scene
- plots that consist of a sequence of events coincidentally happening to the protagonist

And like, sure, on some level, I've known for a while that writing skill doesn't matter to publishers as much as a "marketable" premise. But this is a whole other level of "writing skill doesn't matter."

It's honestly demoralizing, thinking about how this is the kind of garbage agents/publishers think they can make money on and pride in improving the craft doesn't matter to them. I've also been feeling uninspired on the writing front after reading trash book after trash book.

On a more uplifting note, though, I'm a little more at peace with my desire to self-publish this book if it dies in the query trenches. I've seen enough horror stories from authors who have had bad experiences with editors/publishers not marketing their books that I'm more okay with a situation in which I have more control over this book specifically - a book that I have a very specific vision for, know the specific audience I'm targeting, and have a dream cover artist for.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
It sounds weird to say this, but the only way I'm holding onto my sanity right now is by thinking about self-publishing Novel #5 if querying doesn't work out.

Technically, I have a revision plan for Novel #4, but I've been extremely unmotivated to work on the novel. Deep down, I can't shake the thought of "what's the point?"

I think maybe I'll start revising Novel #4 at the end of this year or beginning of next year, so I can try querying it if Novel #5 dies in the query trenches. But given that Novel #4 was on wide submission to editors, I feel even less hopeful about its chances of landing an agent than Novel #5.

I know there's an audience for Novel #5, even if agents/editors don't agree. I'm willing to try to capture that audience through self-publishing if querying fails, because I'm so tired of feeling helpless in the face of the publishing industry. If I do self-publish, though, I think I'd want to expand the story (adding 5-10k words), since I currently feel like the third act of the book is a bit rushed due to my efforts to stay under 120k words.

Sigh.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
Here is the problem I have with many traditionally published queer romances/romantic fantasies: if you've ever spent time reading fanfic, traditionally published stuff is just not as good.

I'm thinking of books like Red, White and Royal Blue, Winter's Orbit, The Kingdoms, or Sorcery and Small Magics (which hasn't come out yet, but I read an ARC of it). People tell me I should find these books swoony, but I do not. These romances are as compelling to me as stale bread. They're just...bad.

And I'm not saying that I only like fanfic because of my favorite ships or whatever. I've also read and enjoyed indie-published queer romances as well as Chinese danmei novels. I have a similar experience reading all these works, regardless of specific genre (contemporary romance, paranormal romance, fantasy romance, sci-fi romance), trope, or heat level: I get characters who are compelling as individuals but who also make sense as a couple I want to root for.

That sounds like a low bar, right? And yet traditionally published queer romances are SO bad at meeting that bar.

One thing that all the traditionally published books I listed above has in common is that they're all written by white people. To be fair, so were most of the indie-published queer romances I've enjoyed (so #NotAllWhite People, before anyone comes after me), but something about these romances are just SO poorly written to me. I don't understand what other people see in them unless there is a ton of projection going on. Like, WHERE is the romantic tension? WHERE is the yearning? WHERE is the deep, nuanced character work? WHERE are the scenes where the characters understand each other/enjoy being in each other's company?

I don't know what goes into the thought processes of agents, editors, and acquisitions teams. Are the stale, tension-less queer romances the ones that feel "safe" for them to acquire? Is stripping queer romances of emotion the only way they are "acceptable" to publish? I really want to know.

It's so frustrating to me because I WANT traditionally published queer romances that make me swoon, that take over my life, that I want to tell all my friends to read. But right now, I only get those feelings from danmei, so those are the only books I really look forward to. SIGH.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
I usually don't feel compelled to write my thoughts about books until I'm done, but maybe it's the combination of my nerves being on edge from querying and recent events in my personal life, or maybe this book is bothering me just that much.

I requested an ARC (advanced reader's copy) of Sorcery and Small Magics by Maiga Doocy (from Orbit Books, publishing this October) after reading the first two chapters in an online excerpt and enjoying them. Now I'm nearly 25% of the way through and feeling like this book has already become a slog.

I want to say for the record that I try not to request ARCs of books unless I really want to read them and really think (or hope) I'll enjoy them. I'm an aggressive DNF'er when it comes to books in general and hate being stuck with a book I'm not enjoying, so because I feel pressure to finish ARCs I receive, I try to only request books that I believe I'll enjoy enough to finish.

Before I received my ARC, I read an online review that said the book felt like fanfiction of The Untamed. That made me apprehensive, but I assumed that maybe the two romantic leads would follow the same trope. Tropes can't be copyrighted, after all. Even as a writer myself, I love writing opposites attract/the sunshine one falls for the reserved, grumpy one.

Unfortunately, the similarities are too close as to be distracting.

Leo Loveage, the narrating protagonist, is an alcohol-loving, free-spirited, prank-playing, rules-hating character who even practices forbidden magic. Like, come on, my guy.

At the same time, he's different from Wei Wuxian in one crucial aspect: rather than being clever and a genius, Leo is more the Walking Mess type of character. And this is a pretty crucial difference, because it makes him much, MUCH more annoying to read about.

You can forgive Wei Wuxian's antics because his cleverness makes him fun to follow and makes it more understandable as to why he's constantly bending rules. Even though he antagonizes Lan Wangji, he has the energy of a rambunctious, mischievous, but ultimately harmless puppy who nevertheless wants to befriend Lan Wangji (at least in the C-drama). Leo Loveage, on the other hand, constantly antagonizes Sebastian Grimm for no reason other than he likes to cause trouble and annoy him. I don't know how old he's supposed to be, but given that this is an adult novel, it makes him seem immature rather than endearing. Combined with the fact that Leo is consistently terrible with magic and seems determined not to find a solution for that in order to spite his family, it quickly becomes grating to be in his head.

I don't easily find characters annoying. I also generally like Walking Disaster-type characters, characters who are presented as being messed up, who drink too much, and whose lives are out of control, usually due to past/family trauma. But I think it's the fact that Leo has no goal or desires and can't stop himself from making his life worse that bugs the hell out of me.

The other part that bothers me is that the magic system feels eerily like the author took cultivation from The Untamed and slapped a European coat of paint on it. The system of scriving spells onto paper sounds a lot like paper talismans, and the absolute dead giveaway was the fact that these sorcerers are also taught swordplay. Combining swordsmanship with magic has always been a very Asian, if not Chinese, fantasy tradition.

Why does this bug me? Because Chinese cultivation fantasy is not exactly well represented in American publishing. Very few, if any, Chinese fantasy novels published in the US actually draw from the Chinese fantasy tradition of cultivation---which to me is an indictment of what Chinese fantasy novels US publishers deem "worthy" of publication. So yeah, it bugs me more than a little that slapping a pseudo-European coat of paint on Chinese traditions is deemed palatable while actual Chinese fantasies drawing from that same tradition are not.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
I'm trying to distract myself from querying by overhauling my skincare routine, lol. I don't like spending a lot of money on skincare, but my skin has been looking bad, so it's probably time to upgrade my cleanser (and maybe my moisturizer). And I'm finally going to tackle smoothing out my skin tone and getting rid of the milia on my face.

I mentioned before that I can't distract myself with a new writing project because it typically takes me a year to a year and a half to come up with an idea I'm passionate enough to write. Or, in other words, it takes a year or more before I feel like I have something to say, enough to write a book about it. It's like I pour myself into every book I write, and I drain myself so completely of thoughts and emotions that it takes a long time for the dry well to refill.

I've been thinking, and maybe the reason why I've been spiraling so hard is that this round of querying reminds me of the last time I was on submission—with a book that I thought was fantastic, but which met with apathy from editors. The dissonance between expectation and reality is really hard for me to cope with. And it feels like I'm reliving that trauma.

It's also hard not to get frustrated when I see the kinds of books that get agent and editor attention are literally the same old, bland, mid-sounding white people fantasies. It's like publishing as a whole has decided "we don't want to pretend we care about BIPOC anymore." Even though, as a reader, the vast majority of my fantasy reading is BIPOC fantasy because I want something different.

Sigh.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
So I haven't posted in a while! It's because the querying process has been stressing. me. out.

Remember how one of my goals was to try to become better at coping with publishing stress? Yeah, I've been failing at that so far. I've realized that a BIG anxiety trigger for me is expecting something to happen soon, but not knowing exactly when, and also feeling like I have no control over the result. That was exactly the reason why I coped so poorly with being on submission for Novel #4 last year, and it's why I haven't been dealing well with querying right now. :(

Querying...hasn't been going well so far. I ended up panic-withdrawing a bunch of my initial queries after a string of rejections because I was pretty sure something was wrong with my query letter. I revised the query letter, but I do feel bad, wondering if maybe the earlier agents rejected it because my query letter didn't do the story justice. It's tough, because I feel like this is a fantastic book, but no one's been interested so far.

I mean, I guess to be fair, I felt that way about Novel #4 too, and now in hindsight I can see problems with it. But that just leads me to a whole new paranoia—am I so bad at judging what's a commercial story that I can't trust my own taste? If so, that would make it seem like I should just give up on traditional publishing, because I can't even identify what a marketable story is.

It sucks too because there's nothing I can use to take my mind off querying. I'm not the kind of writer who can jump into a new project right away, given that it usually takes me about a year after finishing one book before I have enough ideas to start a new one. I haven't had any video games to play since Tears of the Kingdom. And I haven't been having a great reading year, either—many of the new book releases this year I've found to be pretty mediocre so far. (And even when I enjoy a book, I burn through it quickly and then am back to twiddling my thumbs. The downside of being a fast reader...)

This long weekend in particular has been agonizing for me, because I know an agent has my full and I'm expecting them to get back to me soon. Which suuuuuucks for my anxiety. They've sent me enthusiastic emails so far, but after the initial excitement I felt, I realized that makes me feel worse—because I'm going to feel so much worse if they reject because the rest of the manuscript didn't live up to their expectations. And it's already happened once—another agent from my first round did request the full pretty quickly, but they rejected, and their rejection said they stopped reading halfway through because the book didn't live up to their expectations.

When that first agent requested my full manuscript, I was hopeful, but I had a prickling sense of dread too—like "I'm afraid to hope for an offer of representation from the first agent who requested, because my publication journey has never been that easy." Now I'm trying to make peace with the possibility that this second agent will reject, too. In which case, I'll be back to waiting around to see if any of the other agents I queried will request the full. Sigh...
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
Well, I'm officially in the query trenches again. It seems that querying has gotten slower every year, so I'm desperately trying to figure out what to do to occupy my mind so I'm not just sitting around anxiously waiting for news.

In theory, my backup plan if Novel #5 dies in the query trenches is to rewrite Novel #4 and query that. Currently, though, I feel like I'm still too close to that book to effectively think of ways to rewrite it. I'm waiting for my critique partner to return from a trip so we can brainstorm together.

I've definitely been feeling too tired (and burned out by the publishing industry) to write something new. It doesn't help matters that I don't feel like I've read a good book in forever. I find myself rewatching The Untamed/Mo Dao Zu Shi and Scumbag System to entertain myself. :')

Speaking of, while I still dearly wish and hope to see Scumbag System season 2 one day, the shine has rubbed off the story as a whole for me, mostly because I feel like there are just way too many consent problems with the latter third of the book. Honestly, maybe a censored screen adaptation would fix the relationship issues, in a way...?

It's also fun for me to think about how MDZS and Scum Villain really feel like two sides of the same coin. It feels to me like Mo Xiang Tong Xiu started Scum Villain as a parody of tropes, and then decided to write MDZS to play the tropes straight and justify them. Both stories have a "villain protagonist" (who dresses in red and black, to boot!) who were orphaned at a young age, were thrown off a cliff and thereafter gained "demonic" power.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
My revisions for Novel #5 are done, I'm ready to query (just waiting on feedback on my query materials from someone who hopefully will respond this week), and now I'm trying to refill my creative well because I'm feeling drained of ideas.

And...I'm not having much luck.

While I've read some books I've enjoyed so far this year, none of them have "wowed" me. Even my four-star reads are books that I mostly forget about a week later—which is deeply painful, given my autistic self loves nothing more than to latch onto a new special interest and obsess over it for a month.

I have yet to rate a book 5 stars this year. Even books I've enjoyed have had issues that prevent me from loving them: character development that wasn't done well enough, wooden dialogue, meandering plot, "show don't tell" problems. As one example, I tried reading Darker By Four by June Tan, which just recently came out. And I just...became too aggravated to keep reading by the 20% point. All of the characters were paper-thin and poorly established. The beginning had no plot momentum. I couldn't believe the book was published like that, when any debut author trying to get a book like that published would be laughed out of the industry by editors.

I don't know what the problem is. Quality of books declining due to editor burnout, or the industry's focus on hook and premise over execution? Gatekeepers doing a poor job of publishing books that are actually compelling? It's interesting to watch Goodreads pages for upcoming books and see there are books that lack buzz from advance readers—sometimes due to the quality of the book, but sometimes this happens to books that are reviewed well. Books that were enjoyed by most of the readers who read them, yet not enough for readers to rave about them to their friends.

Honestly, the books I find myself most excited for these days are danmei novels. :( Because I can at least be guaranteed a plot that moves and interesting characters that I care about. Meanwhile, reading tradpub releases feels like playing roulette: Am I going to enjoy this book, or am I going to hate it?
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
The weirdest feeling I've ever had is when I want to be writing but have nothing to write.

Looking back over my personal records, since 2015, I've written one book every two years. It's not a reflection of the speed with which I draft/revise, but rather, I don't seem to get an idea I'm truly passionate about writing until a year or so has passed since the last book I wrote.

Maybe that's the natural outcome when most of my books are personal to me in some way - I only have something to say about my own experiences when enough time has passed for me to have new thoughts/experiences/reflections. Though I have a commercial sensibility, I can't seem to write books solely for a commercial purpose.

But yeah, it's a very strange feeling when I want to be writing but feel like my head is empty of ideas. T_T
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (moon knight 2)
I am—very slowly—working on edits for Novel #4, and I may have had a revelation?

Whenever I feel "bored" by chapter openings—usually when a chapter begins with setting description—I try to rewrite the descriptions to make them "voicier" (or more active). And now I'm starting to wonder, is THIS the secret sauce I was missing when I went on submission with this book?

I've read two books recently that I thought had amazing voice: Everyone On This Train Is a Suspect by Benjamin Stevenson, and Voyage of the Damned by Francis White. Maybe that's why I'm suddenly paying a lot more attention to voice now. In particular, I feel like I've (semi-consciously) picked up the idea that voice can really come through in physical descriptions and choice of metaphors.

I do feel like I'm improving Novel #4, but I'm becoming a little paranoid, too. Voice, for me, is something I have not really prioritized since I spend most of my energy while drafting thinking hard about character and plot. And then, while editing, I often have to look for places to add physical descriptions because that's a weakness of mine. Dialogue is a strong point for me, but voice in the narrative is something that I tend not to think about beyond a sentence here or there. To put it another way, voice has always been intuitive for me in the past.

The idea of voice as something I have to consciously craft? It makes me scared that my tiny brain doesn't have the space to pay attention to yet ANOTHER consideration while drafting/editing. Especially since my neurodivergent brain has a hard time verbalizing to begin with.

Sigh. Maybe I'll noodle on this some more.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
I've read a bunch of books over the past week, and at least three of them had romantic subplots that I really didn't care for. And I've been thinking about why.

Sometimes I (half-jokingly) think I'm just not allocishet enough to appreciate heterosexual romances between cis and allo characters anymore, but I'm starting to think there's something more specific to it.

The three books I read recently all had the same problem. The male love interests turned into major simps for the female protagonists for no real reason we're shown in the page. And that's why I fell out of love with the romantic subplots.

It does feel like a specific kind of wish fulfillment when it comes from female authors (who I assume are allocishet themselves). Like, the idea of wanting a man who will die for the female character but is kind of flat and amorphous as an actual person. I don't necessarily think authors do this on purpose, but I wonder if the romances end up this way due to confirmation bias from the author. As in, the author thinks this couple is cute, so they believe the reader will think the couple is cute too, without actually doing much to show why. (Which is something you can get away with in fanfic, but not in original fiction.)

I used to not enjoy most M/F romances because the guy was always a jerk. But "paper cut-out perfect BF" is, while less problematic, not emotionally engaging for me, either. I want to know why the two romantic leads like each other in order to buy a romantic plot. Why they work well together, why they complement each other, why they enjoy each other's company.

I don't know, I wish there could be more fantasy novels published without a major M/F romantic plot. Or maybe have a M/M romantic plot instead, but those are still vanishingly rare for some reason.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
Now that I'm close to done with the first draft of Novel #5, I have a better idea of my plans/timeline for the beginning of the year. This is still a bit aspirational/optimistic, since it relies on me finishing my draft by the end of this weekend and finishing my edits by the end of the month, so we'll see...

End of January 15: Finish drafting Novel #5.

I may also send the rough version of Part III to my first beta reader for initial feedback.

End of January: Finish editing Novel #5.

February: Send Novel #5 to my beta readers at the beginning of the month, with the aim of obtaining their feedback by the end of the month.

While waiting for beta reader feedback, I plan on:

- Workshopping and finalizing my query letter
- Asking the author groups I'm part of for agent whisper lists or recommendations, and putting out feelers to see if I can get any referrals
- Taking a break from all this hectic drafting/revision
- Working on scheduling an eye doctor appointment and taking care of any other chores left over from last year

March: Finish revising Novel #5. Hopefully, I won't need to make any significant revisions. If that's the case, then I will finalize my query list and send out my queries some time during the month (I plan to shotgun all my queries since my list will be small).

March onward: I have no idea how long the query process will take. Possibly months. I also know I can't bank on the idea that this book will land an agent, and if this book dies in the query trenches, that process will also take months, possibly a year or more. So, here's what I plan to do:

- More relaxing. (Seriously, after writing 40k words over 10 days at the end of 2023, I think I need to step away from Microsoft Word for a while.)
- Any chores I didn't manage to do during February.
- Rereading, brainstorming ideas, and (gently, as in not rushing or grinding) revising Novel #4 in case Novel #5 dies in the query trenches.

Non-writing things I'm looking forward to this year:
- Books!
- Rebel Moon Part 1 & 2
- Bo: Path of the Teal Lotus
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
I've wanted to write this post for a while now, except my mind got stuck in the loop of "I want to write about Yellowface but I don't want to read the book because RF Kuang is on my personal hate list" and for some reason, it only just occurred to me that I could just write a blog post about it, lol.

For those who don't know, Yellowface by RF Kuang is a literary fiction novel about a white woman who steals her Chinese American friend's manuscript and passes it off as her own (I've linked the Goodreads page if you want to read a more detailed summary). I decided not to read the book myself because I was burned by RF Kuang after Babel. I did enjoy the first two books in the Poppy War trilogy, but thought the third book was a muddled mess in terms of character arcs and messaging. Babel made me suspect that RF Kuang has developed a bit of an ego after experiencing so much publishing success. And now, here we are.

I enjoyed Cindy's video about the book, and the point about RF Kuang's own financial privilege is an important one that even I didn't know. But something that I don't see enough people talking about is RF Kuang's privileged publishing journey, which for me calls into question just how much of an authority she can be on racism in publishing.

RF Kuang has had a charmed journey through publishing, especially for an author of color. The first book she queried, she landed an agent with it. She went on submission and sold her debut (I assume quickly) at auction to a Big 5 publisher in a "significant" deal (which means $251,000 to $499,000). Her debut may not have been a New York Times bestseller, but it sold very well and earned out its significant advance within a few months, if my memory serves me correctly. Every book deal of hers since then has been for a lot of money. Babel also sold in a "significant" deal. Yellowface alone sold in a "major" deal, which means $500,000 or more. This is the kind of success most authors in general, let alone authors of color, dream of.

Given all this, I just can't take RF Kuang seriously as an "expert" on racism in the publishing industry when she's never had to deal with the most significant gatekeeping authors of color face: difficulty landing an agent, selling a book to a publisher, and earning an adequate advance for our books.

So many authors of color struggle for years to get an agent. So many more have their first book, or even multiple books, die on submission. (I fall into both of these camps.) And even those authors of color who land a book deal are often paid peanuts and have to persevere for years before finally having their big break and being able to earn anywhere near livable advances (if they ever do).

My feeling from reading Babel and a few interviews is that RF Kuang thinks rather highly of her own intellect. It wouldn't surprise me if she assumes that whatever difficulties she may have faced in the industry constitute the worst, most racist experiences ever (including the experience of getting one-star reviews on Goodreads, which is just a majorly cringey attitude). I find that many authors who don't interact much with other authors fall into this insular view. In one interview, Kuang criticized the character of Athena Liu from Yellowface as someone who never uplifts other Asian American authors—and yet I don't recall ever seeing Kuang herself uplifting other Asian American authors, either.

I've seen some people who were awed by the fact that Kuang was able to publish this "exposé" on the publishing industry. But that itself is a marker of privilege. Kuang was already a bestseller; the industry was willing to take a risk on her that it would never do for an "unproven" author. And for crying out loud, do people really think the publishing industry would be hesitant to publish books "exposing" their secrets if they thought they could make a lot of money doing so? No one, for example, would be willing to publish a book from me that talks about the rejection I received from an editor who said "I already acquired another book about an Asian American protagonist [from a different Asian ethnicity]". Or the rejection I received from an agent who said it was "too much" that my protagonist was queer, Chinese, depressed, anxious, and autistic.

In general, I'm tired of financially privileged Chinese Americans being held up as evidence of how "diverse" the publishing industry is. (And I generally consider myself financially privileged, but some of these authors are on a different level—my parents didn't have enough money when I was young to take the family traveling all the time, for example, and I attended public schools.)
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (moon knight 2)
Happy 2024!

I've just spent the last 10 days in a writing cave, working feverishly on Novel #5. I'm now at 100k out of 120k words, and I think I can finish drafting the book by the end of MLK Day. Then, of course, I'll need to edit and get feedback from my critique partners to make this book the strongest it can be before I can jump back into the query trenches. (Hopefully, the first half of my book is polished enough and I don't need to edit it much, focusing mostly on the second half.) As long as I don't need to do any major rewrites, I think I may be able to query agents in March???

I'm happy with my progress, though I'm also feeling pretty exhausted after drafting 40k words in 10 days. I've learned that I can draft for 4 or 5 days in a row before I start feeling the mental strain of fatigue (I did take a break last Wednesday to slow down and do some editing rather than drafting). I definitely wouldn't have pushed myself this hard if I wasn't trying to get back into the query trenches ASAP; the last time I spent Christmas break drafting, I only wrote about 9k words over the break.

It's interesting. 120k is my maximum wordcount target for this book due to the conventions of the publishing industry, but the book definitely could be longer. It's structured a bit like an anime and it was inspired by Journey to the West, a fantasy adventure epic, so there are more subplots I could add. But I'm trying to keep it lean for the sake of keeping the pacing tight and to avoid giving agents/editors a reason to pass due to the wordcount. (My brain also got tired and ran out of ideas for more fight scenes, haha.)

I still think about my former agent sometimes, and one of the things that hurt me the most from our relationship was when she told me that, instead of trying to see if UK publishers would be interested in Novel #4, it was a *better use of my time* to write a new book and go on submission with that. It's still unbelievable to me that an agent would dictate to their client what they should think the best use of their time is and not understand how condescending that attitude is. At the very least, shouldn't an agent ask how their client felt about that? Like "would you rather continue pursuing publication for this book or, since you're working on something new, would you prefer to focus on that? Let's talk through the pros/cons of each choice"???

I am literally the one doing all the work (especially since I also had to come up with all the pitching and submission strategy for my books!!); I am the one juggling writing books with a day job (since my agent worked as an agent full-time), and I am the one who understands my own writing process, how much time it takes, and the toll it takes on my energy when I decide to write a new novel. Not to mention, my agent can never guarantee that she could sell a new novel I wrote, either!!

It's unbelievable to me, because she always said the right things; she always thanked me for my hard work whenever I turned in a new book or a round of edits to her, seeming to acknowledge my labor. But then she turned around and acted like I should be a book factory who can just crank out books for years with no compensation until I produced one that she could sell in a big deal. I could never work with an agent who took such a cavalier view of my labor. And that was absolutely incompatible for my own vision for my career, which was to grow my career with a publisher who was as invested in my passion projects as I was, even if I have to start small. To get my foot in the door, because even though publishing is unpredictable and doesn't come with any guarantees, it still seems easier to sell a second book once you already have a book published. Plus, you can't build a fanbase if no one can ever read your work.

And, yeah, like I mentioned before, realizing the disconnect between (some of) her words and her actions has definitely left me with deep trust issues and made me wonder what else she lied to me about over the course of our relationship. Like whether she actually did much work to identify the best editors, or whether she even cared about my books. Especially since she had a history of not engaging with me when I had industry questions.

Look, I'm a logical person, and if you show me facts that prove me wrong, then I will change my mind. What drives me absolutely nuts is if I present facts and ask you to explain why those facts are different from what you told me, and you either ignore me or tell me I should *just trust your experience*. That just makes me mad, as well as paranoid that you are either purposefully misleading me or that you're not competent at your job. We can debate whether or not a book is marketable or well-written. We can't debate about the publicly reported size of deals made by publishers or whether or not publishers have distribution in the US.

The way she communicated with me was just baffling. I still don't understand why she felt that the appropriate response to me saying "You seem to be very opposed to UK submission, so I'll let it go, but I want to understand why you're so opposed to it?" was to say for the fourth time that she thought UK submission was a bad idea but we could still do it if I wanted. And then when I said I felt like I was being strung along, her response was to deny it and said we could still do UK submission if I wanted. No attempt to explain herself. No acknowledgement whatsoever that a reasonable person, after being asked *3 times* to confirm that they wanted to do something, may become suspicious when told "I need you to confirm one more time that you want to do this, but I'll still do it if you want to." Like, you're going to have to at least explain your motivations for why you've been acting that way if you expect me to believe you.

Thinking back, there were other times I could have been more direct and pushed her earlier in our relationship, but I always held back out of politeness and fear of sounding like a nag. If I had been more direct then, maybe I could have realized the problems with her sooner, because that's how the house of cards finally came crumbling down when I pressed her on her reasons for not wanting to sub my book to the UK. And I guess that's a lesson I should take going forward into a new agent relationship—not to be afraid of being direct and asking my agent to explain themselves. Because if they can't or won't, that's a major red flag.

I know I'm just ranting about my ex-agent again. Here's to hoping I can find a true advocate in 2024.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
All right, here are my goals for the end of the year and for 2024:

1. Finish Novel #5.

This is my top priority for the near future, to draft and revise Novel #5 so I can jump into the querying trenches again. I'm not sure how long it will take, since my outline for the second half of Novel #5 is much vaguer than my outline for the first half. Ideally, I'd love to wrap this up in a few months, but we'll have to see. (I'll probably have a better idea after seeing how much progress I make during my 10-day work vacation/writing retreat.)

2. Manage my physical and mental health.

I've learned some hard lessons about managing my mental health in the publishing industry this year. I've had a bad mental health year, and I want to improve. I've learned that I can't count on traditional publishing for anything, and I can't just sit around waiting for things to happen. As difficult as it is, the best way to cope is to forget the book exists while I'm querying/on submission and to focus on other things. (Having a better agent who genuinely believes in my work would probably also help!) Since I've been out of the querying trenches for a while and querying is apparently harder than ever, I do want to work on managing my expectations and potential anxiety in case querying doesn't work out.

Because my mental health has been so bad this year (though also because I've been traumatized by the US healthcare system), I've put off addressing some physical health issues. I do want to use next year to address them. Maybe it's not the greatest idea to wait until Novel #5 is done to work on that, since I don't know how long it will take to finish Novel #5? But...that's just how I am. When I'm actively drafting a book, it's hard for me to focus on anything else.

3. Brainstorm and revise Novel #4.

This will be my project while I'm querying, since the only way I can cope with how much the publishing industry is out of my control is by focusing on something I can control. I still believe in the premise of Novel #4 as something hooky and commercial, I still think the characters are great and the worldbuilding is cool. If I revise it enough, I can use it to query in case Novel #5 dies in the query trenches, and it might be able to go on submission again.

But, on the topic of mental health again, I'm not going to push myself to work on anything else besides Novel #5 and Novel #4. (I'd probably be too mentally exhausted to work on something new, anyway.)

4. Other life stuff?

Every year I tell myself I'll start dating again, and every year I end up pushing it off. It's harder than ever to make this resolution since so much of 2024 is going to be up in the air due to finishing Novel #5 and querying. So...we'll see.


I never have reading goals, since I always just read as many books as I'm interested in in a year. But there are a lot of books I'm looking forward to reading next year, plus I recently got a NetGalley account so I'm excited to potentially read some ARCs.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
Well...I know I previously said I would wait to leave my agent until I had a new book ready to query. As it turns out, our relationship very suddenly imploded. Even though I was very angry and hurt by an email she sent me, I tried to lay out my issues and point out that I'm concerned about our communications lately, deciding that I'd give her a chance to explain herself and see if she'll express any willingness to salvage the relationship.

And...she did not.

She said she was sorry for being unclear, but then proceeded to claim I misunderstood what she said, which felt like a defense instead of an apology. Plus, I still think it's unreasonable for her to act like "just because I told you three times that I thought UK submission was a bad idea doesn't mean I was trying to talk you out of it," or even if that truly wasn't her intention, there's no way she can't understand why I would come to that conclusion. Then she wildly misinterpreted something I said in an outrageously unreasonable way and didn't apologize for that at all. Her recent emails have generally felt like they were full of "polite professional-speak" without actually addressing my concerns or truly acknowledging why I might be hurt.

The consensus among my family and friends is that she's purposefully trying to obfuscate how she truly feels, and there's no way I'll ever know for sure what's going through her mind. Still, I'm neurodivergent and I obsess over people's behavior when I don't understand them, so here are the possible interpretations I came up with:

Scenario #1: Assuming that she wasn't completely lying and purposefully trying to mislead me, and that she was being honest this whole time (even though she backtracked on her position and didn't explain why): She is a terrible communicator (for someone who makes a living based on reading), but she cannot accept being challenged and refuses to take accountability for her own bad communication. If she had just said "I completely understand why you read my email that way and I sincerely apologize for not communicating clearly and causing you unnecessary anxiety because that was not what I meant" and said she was willing to discuss how she can improve communicating with me, she would have completely defused my hurt and anger.

In any case, the fact that she seemed unwilling to meet me in the middle feels like she was uninterested in retaining me as a client anyway.

Scenario #2: She was lying about everything the whole time. She didn't want to do UK submission and tried to persuade/manipulate me into dropping the idea; however, when I called her out on it, she tried to backtrack, for reasons I don't understand. My personal theory is that she didn't want to go on submission in the UK because she thought she couldn't earn much money (which would be a massive conflict of interest if true), and when I pointed out to her that UK publishers can offer six-figure deals, she didn't want to acknowledge that I was right and she had been wrong, but that motivated her to backtrack and tell me we could still do UK submission, even though by that point I said I wasn't interested.

She suggested we part ways as a way to get rid of me; however, when I said she brought that up out of nowhere, she again seemed to backtrack. One of my friends suggested she is extremely conflict-averse and was trying to make me happy even if it wasn't what she wanted to do, and also at the cost of communicating any coherent position. I'm not sure if I personally believe that, because even if she was conflict-avoidant, she should have accepted it when I said I was willing to drop UK submission instead of coming back and insisting we could still do it if I wanted to.

I am a very conflict-avoidant person*, and one of the primary ways I avoid conflict is by preemptively apologizing whenever I feel like someone else thinks I might have screwed up. Obviously each person is different, but I'm just not sure I believe that conflict avoidance was her primary motivation for communicating with me the way she did.

(*I'm conflict-avoidant unless/until I feel like conflict is inevitable; once I'm in the middle of a conflict, I can become incredibly aggressive in standing up for myself, and I've noticed that people don't receive that switch well. Sometimes, I suspect that people assume they can bully me into obedience because I usually seem mild-mannered and shy, and then they react badly when I stand my ground and call out their BS.)


All of this is to say, I didn't have the energy to want to argue with her further if she was going to continue sounding this defensive and not receptive to my hurt feelings. So...as of yesterday, I am now agentless again.

I did have to ask her to pull the remaining submissions for Novel #4 and write them off as a loss, but there's a possibility those editors were ghosting me, anyway.

I also have to buckle down and finish Novel #5 in order to query again (querying Novel #4 would be a risk since it's already been on submission to US publishers).

Based on my experience and also speaking with many other authors, no author—and this is even more true for authors who don't have a book deal yet—ever wants to be in the position of terminating with their agent and being back in the query trenches again. While many authors do land another agent, there are also authors who don't. But the industry is so opaque that agents can, quite frankly, get away with treating their clients poorly and authors have very little recourse.

As I mentioned in a previous entry, there are many factors that pushed me to leave my agent. When I look back, there are multiple subtle hints I can now see that make me think my agent prioritized how much money she could make over my desires, which is a massive conflict of interest. I didn't pick up on those red flags at the time, because it's not unusual for an agent to want to get as much money as possible for a client; however, if a client values things other than money, an agent shouldn't pressure them, either. When it looked like a publisher was going to make an offer on Novel #3, my agent sort of pushed me to want a multi-book deal and seemed upset when I said I only wanted a one-book deal. The way my agent easily gives up on my books after they don't sell after one round to all the major publishers now feels like she's no longer interested if she thinks she can't get a big commission. And again, that's a conflict of interest. Money is not the only factor to weigh when considering an offer from a publisher. I've even heard that some agents pressure their clients to take the highest offer if there is a multiple offer situation, even if the author wants to go with an editor with a better vision for their book, and that would be an absolute nightmare scenario to me.

I'm cynical, so I feel like that my agent could probably claim that we parted ways because I was being unreasonable. But I left the relationship because I was starting to get stressed by the idea of interacting with her. Because I don't want an agent who is defensive, who hides or lies about their motivations, who is unwilling to have open and honest discussions with me even if those discussions are difficult.

I want an agent who believes in my books enough to fight their hardest for them. I want an agent who understands that this is my career and I need to have the final decision-making authority on issues that affect my career. I want to have an agent I trust enough that we can have discussions about the industry, about difficult situations and how to strategize if my career isn't going well, instead of suspecting that they might want to persuade me to one course of action or another for their own reasons.

Fingers crossed that I'll be able to find my advocate next year.

Profile

rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
rainwaterspark

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 24th, 2025 02:12 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios