rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (moon knight 2)
Reading fanfic of Chinese source material is always frustrating to me, because I can't tell whether fanfic authors are of Chinese descent or not and it often seems like cultural nuances are messed up.

And I want to be kind to fanfic authors, plus some part of me wonders whether these "mistakes" are possibly intentional choices to call back to the source material. But I can't tell, and if unintentional, these mistakes are as bothersome as mosquito bites.

For example, I was reading one Erha (The Husky and His White Cat Shizun) fanfic that was an Edo period Japan AU. Overall, I enjoyed it...but what bothered me was how the names were handled. See, people in Japan wouldn't pronounce Mandarin names; they would pronounce the characters according to how they're pronounced in Japanese.

So "Taxian-jun" would never be called that in Japan. It would be something like "Fusen-sama" (according to my mediocre Google-fu; an actual Japanese-speaker can feel free to correct me). Especially because the character "jun" in Chinese, a respectful honorific, is "kun" in Japanese, which is informal.

Another fanfic I was reading, this time for SVSSS (The Scum Villain's Self-Saving System), was an imperial Chinese AU in which the two versions of Shen Qingqiu and Luo Binghe all existed and they were all twins. Which was cute. Except...it bothered me how the younger twins would refer to their older brothers: Shen Yuan called his brother "Jiu-ge" and Luo Binghe called his brother "Bing-ge."

That's...not how you refer to your brothers in Chinese culture. Using a given name + "ge" is how you would refer to a good (older male) friend. For your actual familial brother, you would call them "Gege" or "Ge."

(deep sigh)
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (moon knight 2)
I don't consider myself a major fanfic writer; I've flitted in and out of fandoms over the years, and I haven't felt the urge to write fanfic for every fandom I've fallen in love with. (It usually has to be for a franchise that has a lot of holes in the canon to fill in.) Specifically, I've gone from writing Captain America fanfic in 2014 to The Old Guard fanfic in 2020 and now to Moon Knight fanfic in 2022; basically, I've gone long periods without feeling the urge to write fanfic.

But you know what's the great part about fanfic?

It's the fact that you only do it if you love it.

Let me rewind a little to talk about what I've been doing for the last nine months.

I got an agent at the beginning of 2021 and naively thought I was close to the end of my publication journey for Novel #3. Instead, I've been weathering rejection after rejection, many of which claimed my book wasn't commercial enough.

I'm a mood writer. I never force myself to write a story that I don't love and believe in. But I think traditional publishing's focus on a high concept did subconsciously filter into my brain. In October of 2021, I began drafting a fantasy story that was high concept and that I thought had a good shot at getting publisher interest (I mean, assuming publishers hadn't already acquired another vaguely similar Asian fantasy, because of publishing's "there can only be one" mentality regarding books by authors of color...sigh).

And again, I loved this story idea! I followed a similar pattern to when I was drafting my other stories, e.g. I drafted the first 20k-30k rapidly because I was so excited.

It took me almost seven months, working almost nonstop on this manuscript, to finish drafting and complete one round of revisions. By that point, I was feeling incredibly burned out on the manuscript. Even though I started out loving it, I was starting to feel a tremendous amount of pressure due to feeling like I wouldn't have a shot at a book deal unless this book was already perfect when it went on submission. I was also writing in a genre that I was less familiar with (genre mystery as opposed to genre romance). So I was just feeling bad about the whole thing.

Around the same time that I sent my draft off to more critique partners so I could take a complete break from looking at it, I started to watch the Moon Knight TV show and loved it. Well, up until the end, as I've detailed in other blog posts. But this was the first time since The Old Guard that I felt inspired to write fanfic again, so I did.

And...honestly, I've been loving this experience.

It felt so good to write without any pressure again. It also felt amazing to work on shorter pieces that I could polish to a shine—I do enjoy micro-editing, but I rarely get around to it for my novel-length works because I'm so focused on the plot and character arcs.

I have 3 Moon Knight fanfics posted and am planning on posting at least 2 more, though honestly, I never even dreamed I would be posting this many fics at all. And I still enjoy tinkering and experimenting with fanfic ideas, regardless of whether they come to fruition or not.

Basically, writing fanfic again has reminded me of how to fall in love with writing again.
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (moon knight 2)
(New fandom, who dis? lol)

Despite my problems with the MCU Moon Knight show, I found myself reading fanfiction just because waiting for the next Moon Knight comic issue is hard, haha. (And fanfic for comics-continuity Moon Knight is mostly nonexistent.)

Obligatory self-promo for my own Moon Knight fanfics: https://archiveofourown.org/users/cyanspark/works?fandom_id=66924490


"Moon Knight meets the Avengers" fics

do not enter is written on the doorway (but you can stay) by Some_Dead_Guy

Moon Knight in the MCU (series) by goldenambedo

Moon Knight and Sam Wilson by god_hates_tyler

of all your sacred vows by notmadderred


Other Moon Knight fics

The Absence of Fear (And Other Lies We Tell Ourselves) by Pokimoko
A Steven-centric fic about his childhood. Heartbreaking in how it shows the way Steven comprehends his situation and his relationship with his parents.

In the Absent Place (Listening To Silence On The Radio) by Pokimoko
A sequel to "The Absence of Fear (And Other Lies We Tell Ourselves)" but it can also stand alone. Steven Grant thinks he lives in a haunted house and his only friend is an internet pen pal named "M." It's fairly obvious what's really going on (also, the tags more or less give it away). Cool premise.

Home Cooked Meal by haliaZ
Steven and Marc cook a meal for Jake. Sort of fluff, sort of angst.

so this could be the death of me (or maybe just a better me) by darkerintheday
One time Marc saves Steven, one time Jake saves Marc, and one time Steven saves Jake.

Rhythm, Interrupted by staranon
An introspective fic about Marc's feelings before the start of the show.

One Fish, Two Fins by TweetStweet
A fic about how Marc (and Jake!) replace Gus in episode 1. I love this headcanon!

hardwired instincts by blackleaders
A fic about autistic Steven and autistic Marc. :)

she takes what you give her (and maybe you'll find it) by acatalepsy
Set after episode 2 - Marc and Layla talk about his DID.

quarter of a million miles to the moon by priide
A Jake character study.

There Goes My Mind by CXMP_14 [crossover]
A short oneshot that's a crossover between Moon Knight and Star Wars (the new trilogy) (because...Oscar Isaac), where Marc, Steven, and Jake are Poe's alters and Poe is also the avatar of Khonshu, though he doesn't know it. This was cute (I loved the cashew/Khonshu joke).

Avatar: The Moon Knight by AuthorLoremIpsum, ButterflyBeeStevenwithaV [AU] [crossover]
A Moon Knight x Avatar: The Last Airbender crossover. The writing...could use some improvement, though at least it's not distractingly bad. But this is such a seamless crossover that I find myself enjoying it nonetheless. Plus, this may be my favorite fanfic depiction of Jake ever!

You Stay Soft, Get Beaten by SpacelessCass [series in progress]
Steven wakes up in Dr. Harrow's office again, but this time Marc and Jake aren't there, and it's up to Steven to save himself. Goes really deep into Steven's insecurities. Also, I love the way Steven cares about and defends Marc and Jake.
 

Marc and Steven (and/or sometimes Layla) meet Jake fics

So...I'm not sure I would say I love these fics, since I have a lot of thoughts about how I wish Jake was portrayed. But at the very least, these are probably the best-written fics with this trope, in my opinion.

not quite a meet-cute by notmadderred

the third passenger by Nanashi07

First Meetings by reflectiveless

rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
(New fandom, who dis??)

The Old Guard is the first fandom I’ve been part of ever since Captain America six years ago (so long ago, yeesh). Reading fanfic for this fandom is somewhat agonizing at times considering the vast majority of the historical fanfic have egregious errors when it comes to historical accuracy, sigh. I’ve managed to find a few fanfics that I like, though. (Most of these are Joe/Nicky fanfics unless otherwise stated.)

(As always, this is a work in progress!)


Recommendations:

try it again (breathing’s just a rhythm) by bookerapologist
This is a Booker-centric fanfic that takes place after the events of the movie. It’s beautiful and exquisitely heartbreaking. I can’t recommend it enough.

A Past Life Bleeding Through by idiom [AU] [crossover]
Ever thought that a crossover between The Old Guard and Assassin’s Creed would be perfect? This fic has got you covered.

Lion Hearts by romeoandjulietyouwish
The ace Joe/Nicky fanfic of my heart. :)

how could something so bad look so damn good? by FereldenTurnip [crossover]
This is a crossover between The Old Guard and the FX TV show Trust, where Luca Marinelli played an Italian gangster named Primo Nizzuto, and it’s hilarious.

The Two Sides of Forever by CypressSunn
The one historical Joe/Nicky fanfic that doesn’t make me want to jump into a lake (also, it’s rather sweet).

Cat and Crown by Wind_Ryder [AU]
This is a fantasy AU without a romance between Joe and Nicky. Yusuf is a Giver, someone who can heal and raise the dead with a touch, while Nicky is a Reaper, someone who can kill with a touch, and they are on opposite sides of an endless war. There’s political intrigue and an interesting magic system and world.


Missed You By a Few Minutes, a Few Centuries by just_another_tinker [AU]
A canon-divergent AU where Joe and Nicky didn’t realize they’ve met in the Crusades and neither knows the other is immortal. This fic is major angst city.


Runners-up:

let not time deceive you (you cannot conquer time) by Draco_sollicitus [AU]
AU where Joe is immortal and Nicky is mortal. This is well written and started off promisingly, but I didn’t really like some of the character choices later. Also, there’s some casual transphobia, sigh.

the other side of this wide night by mellyflori [AU]
No immortality, modern day AU. This is probably the strangest concept I’ve ever seen for a Joe/Nicky fanfic, but it’s written in a surprisingly engaging way.

in the shape of the dead by novaquill [AU] [crossover]
The Old Guard and The Umbrella Academy crossover (a.k.a. the immortals have superpowers). I don't have any feelings about The Umbrella Academy, but I thought this fic was pretty interesting.

All Things Sacred by Valhela [AU] [crossover]
Crossover with Captain America: The Winter Soldier, where Nicky is the Winter Soldier.

Retrograde by Pinkninja
[AU] [crossover]
Crossover with The Time Traveler’s Wife. I didn’t like TTTW as a movie/concept, but I find this fic really well done and can’t wait to see what happens next.

Lights Out by Avelera [in progress]
There are several different "Nicky gets amnesia and forgets Joe" fanfics, but I think this one is my favorite.

all hail the algorithm by silvyri [AU] [in progress]
Modern day AU where Joe and Nicky are matched by a dating algorithm but think the match is a mistake. Great premise, and Nicky with self esteem issues makes my heart hurt in the best way.
rainwaterspark: Image of Link at the Earth Temple in Skyward Sword (legend of zelda skyward sword earth temp)
It's been 2 years (!!) since I wrote "Look into my eyes and tell me if I'm real," a 20k-word-long fanfic inspired by the Captain America: The Winter Soldier comic arc (and conceptualized before the movie came out, I'll never stop saying). I have to admit that I haven't been back to reread the fic since I first posted it, because unfortunately anxiety over my writing appeal caused me to spiral into depression and I've sort of been afraid to trigger those feelings again. (I really should reread it at some point; I'm just not entirely sure when.)

But there is something I'd like to say, regarding what I would do differently if I were to rework this fic today.

When I first wrote the fic, I didn't have a good understanding of autism or neurodiversity. Looking back, though, I'd definitely love to recast the Winter Soldier in that fic as autistic. He already ticks off the boxes in terms of awkwardness in social interactions, difficulty understanding other people, alexithymia, and difficulty outwardly expressing emotion (which leads other people to assume he's emotionless or incapable of emotion). It wouldn't have been hard to add, say, sensory processing difficulties or some other autistic traits.

Anyway...that's just a thought I had. I certainly have my hands full currently with Project E, but maybe autistic Winter Soldier is an idea I'll come back to...some day.
rainwaterspark: Image of Link at the Earth Temple in Skyward Sword (legend of zelda skyward sword earth temp)
There's a weird thing about being a writer and being critical.

Like, in some cases, if you're a reader and you're super-critical, it's okay. But if you're a writer, it's totally Not Okay to criticize another writer's work. And this is even stronger in fandom, where it feels hard to criticize a writer's work at all (at least at AO3; FF.net still has people posting concrit reviews, sometimes).

I guess it seems like, the community thing is to be supportive of each other's work, so being critical is frowned upon.

But I wonder: why?

I think critically and analytically about what I read. I don't want to be seen as someone who purposely flames others' writing, but when I read something, I like to think and talk about what worked for me and what didn't work. That's not flaming.

Usually I don't like talking about people's work behind their backs—i.e. if I'm going to criticize a fanfic, I'd prefer to do it in a comment directly on the fanfic itself. But I'm terrified of, again, becoming seen as a troll or something, so I'm in this weird place where I'm not going to stop talking about others' writing critically, but I'll only do it in an obscure corner of the internet where I think no one will see it.

Read more... )

Ooosh.

Jul. 27th, 2014 10:38 pm
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
It's been almost two months since my last LJ post, which is pretty unusual, since I'm usually pretty active on LJ, if only posting about random things.

So what happened during the last month and a half?

Well...depressed moods and continual teetering on the brink of emotional collapse. Here's a record of what happened on my Wordpress blog:

Basically, it happened because I started posting fanfiction on AO3 and didn't get that much of a response, even though I'm ridiculously proud of my work.

I started not feeling so great.

I thought these feelings would pass given enough time, but that hasn't been the case, and several stressors combined have made me feel even worse.

I've tried to reflect and be rational about what happened, but it's still an ongoing, uphill struggle.

So, in a nutshell: the last month and a half have kind of been a blur. I started slacking off severely at work—not out of laziness, but because I'm chronically exhausted and can't muster up the energy or interest anymore. I've had on and off sleep problems, and while I'm generally not a good sleeper, I definitely tend to experience insomnia when I'm extremely stressed or depressed. I have days when I stare into space and think about the things I need to do and feel a combination of zero ability to get it done and crippling anxiety at the same time. I've had a lot less interest in food and eating recently—which is kind of another thing that I associate with my experiences of depression.

I've babbled quite a bit about my recent writing of fanfiction on this LJ, though mostly in vague terms, and unlike 99% of the other projects I've talked about in the past, I actually finished everything I mentioned, so, I might as well talk about them.

The Hunger Games/Captain America fanfiction, which reached a substantial 14,000 words long, got very little attention. I've made my peace with this, because I realized I was probably too ambitious with this piece. It was a combination crossover fic/criticism of THG/social commentary, which was probably alienating to THG fans and confusing to non-THG fans. (Plus, it wasn't slash, it was actually a little anti-romance, so, you know.)

The other things I've written, though, have made me a bit more upset.

"Not a good man": A Bucky Barnes character study; this is my (somewhat annoyed) reaction to the "woobification" of Bucky that happened in the fandom post-CA:TWS and probably the best writing I've produced on a technical/descriptive/poetic level.

"Look into my eyes and tell me if I'm real": The "monstrous 20,000-word fic that consumed my life" that I've referred to several times before. Over 20,000 words (if you count all the stuff that I had to delete/rewrite) and basically a three-month all-consuming obsession has been a substantial chunk of time, effort, and emotion to invest in this fic; I can honestly write a commentary on this fic that would be as long as a goddamn thesis, explaining why I wrote everything the way I did—every scene, every sentence, every word choice, every freaking punctuation placement. I will never not be proud of this, even though I've come to accept that probably no one will care about this fanfic as much as I do.

Honestly, it hurts. As I said earlier, I thought the pain would lessen over time, but it hasn't, and I don't think I will. School is starting soon in a few weeks, so I guess at this point what would be best for my mental health would be to cut my ties with AO3 almost completely. Which, you know, is really pathetic and anti-promotion and anti-engaging-with-fandom, but I'm not sure what else I can do.

I never planned that writing fanfiction would become a longterm thing for me—partly because my lifelong focus has been original fiction, and partly because there is only so much I can do with the same set of characters before I get bored. So getting more exposure by continuing to write fanfic is kind of out of the question for me. (Not that I've already lost interest in Captain America fanfic, but after writing so much in a relatively short period of time, I've hit a dry spell, and I don't know whether I'll find inspiration again before Cap 3 comes out.) But I'm still proud of what I wrote and I wish I had proof that I'm not delusional.
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
Aaaaaaaarrrggggghhhh apparently I get anxiety when I post new fanfics up now. :(

ANXIETY BEGONE!

Anyway.

I finished my Hunger Games/Captain America fic (and by "finished," I mean "got sick of editing it and threw my hands in the air in frustration"), and based on my difficulties adapting Catching Fire & Mockingjay so far, I think I'll wait to see what people think before continuing. I mean, if no one reads my fic, there doesn't seem to be much point in writing a sequel.

So that just leaves my monstrous 20,000-word fic, which, according to my sister, only needs one scene rewritten before it's fit for public consumption.

Oof.
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
This seems like kind of a random place to put this, but I didn't know where else this would go.

I've spent so much time reading fanfic in the wake of Captain America: The Winter Soldier that I actually have a whole rec list now. Not a long list, since I'm fairly picky when it comes to fanfic, but still. All are based on the movieverse unless otherwise noted (AU or comicsverse). I've put [E] next to the explicit/NSFW fanfics, just in case anyone wants to know.

Also, this is a work in progress. I'll keep adding to this when I find new fics.


- The sirens and the thunder – selkie!Bucky AU
Absolutely gorgeously written. Check out the author (legete)'s other stuff, too.

- don't trust the shining moon - nonexplicit Steve/Bucky relationship, synesthete!Bucky

- Captain Hot Perfect Teacher – no powers AU

- What we find in the telling – post-CA:TWS

- Pretending – asexual!Bucky (:D)
Content note: implied non-consensual relationships

- might have inhaled you - James Bond crossover AU

- Strictly no hugging, no kissing – Pushing Daisies crossover AU [E]
The author captures the style of Pushing Daisies really well, and this fic is very sweet.


- A catalog of non-definitive acts – post-apocalyptic AU [in progress]
Beautifully written. Just incredibly beautiful.


- Enhanced – Steve/Bucky friendship, post-CA:TWS [in progress]
Trigger warning: OCD, sensory processing disorder



I've decided to include a few more fics under the cut that aren't quite on my rec list, but still noteworthy.

Read more... )

Ugh...

Jan. 26th, 2010 08:52 pm
rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (kh birth by sleep ven)
fanfiction.shurtugal.com/viewuser.php

My eyes feel bloody burnt out, and I've spent far too much time today not doing work.

The story goes like this:

Last night, at around 9, I had finished all my work and was bored, because it was too early to go to bed. I remembered I had saved a link I found on the Anti-Shurtugal LJ, a link to some Inheritance fanfiction wrtier, and since stuff from the AS LJ is usually trustworthy, I opened up some of the wrtier's fanfic and started reading. So I read.

And read.

And read.

Until it was 11:30 and I thought, "$%&@, I have to go to sleep because I have an 8:30 class tomorrow."

Yes, the fanfiction was that good. Basically, it has Galbatorix as the protagonist and Eragon as a whiny, moronic brat. Oh, and actually intelligent dragons. Loads of them.

As soon as I finished, I started reading the sequels. Unfortunately, that's when it went downhill.

Brief impressions )


EDIT: My life has well and truly gone to hell. Impressions of the prequels )

Profile

rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
rainwaterspark

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 11th, 2025 12:44 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios