rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
- Is there going to be no end to the times Laurel gets Damsel in Distress-ed? The frequency of it is starting to become disturbing.

- So...we have Sebastian Blood, who's Latino, and a villain (moreover, a villain being ordered around by a bigger mastermind villain who's a white man), and next week the villain looks like a black man. Oh, and let's not forget China White from season one, a villain-for-hire. Someone's probably going to say "But most of the villains are white, not PoC!" True...except look at the tally of PoC in general in this show. Apart from those 3 villains, we have Yao Fei (dead), Shado (brutally fridged for TWO men's manpain), Detective McKenna (effectively erased from the show), Laurel's friend Joanna (also disappeared since Season 1), Frank Chen (dead), Detective Lance's partner (fridged), and Diggle (alive).* Nope, Diggle being an awesome character does not outweigh EVERY OTHER POC being either villainous, dead, or Put On a Bus.

(* I'm sure I'm missing some characters; if I am missing major ones, let me know.)

Arrow 2x09

Dec. 12th, 2013 12:35 pm
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
[Warning: There are MASSIVE SPOILERS in this post.]

The good:

- We actually got to see Barry Allen's lightning strike?! I dunno...on one hand, that's probably the best way to drum up support for the Flash spin-off TV series, because it was pretty epic. On the other hand, I feel like the Flash pilot would be really confusing to new viewers if it picked up directly after that, or even if (God forbid) they skip over it entirely and just start with him trying to figure out his new powers. Ugh, I don't know, I just really want a Flash TV series and I want it to be good and self-contained.

The bad:

- Oh great, Arrow, thanks for fridging a Woman of Color for not just one, but TWO men's manpain. I see you still have issues with writing women, show.

- Also, thanks for killing of a Man of Color in this episode as well, I really appreciated that. /sarcasm

The iffy:

- Roy Harper getting injected with the superserum is super ehh. Frankly I don't know why they went down that route, because in the comics Roy (a.k.a. Speedy/Red Arrow/Arsenal) is, like Green Arrow and the Batfamily, one of the select comic heroes who doesn't have superpowers. And considering how Arrow in general doesn't seem to like superpowers, I thought they would've stuck with that. But, y'know, whatever, it's not like Arrow particularly cares about DC continuity in the first place...

At first I thought, yay, Barry Allen's last appearance on this show means I can stop watching Arrow and just wait for Flash! Except I think I'm going to have to watch again if they address Roy becoming Red Arrow/Arsenal, ugh.
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
I loved 2x08 "The Scientist." I love Grant Gustin's take on Barry Allen, who's such a lovable geeky dork but also really earnest. You get the feeling that a lot of his smiling and awkward joke attempts are used to bandage his childhood trauma and cover up the fact that though he's highly intelligent, he's a little insecure and uncomfortable in his skin.

For the most part, internet reaction to Grant Gustin!Barry Allen seems to be positive, though of course there are still people who are like "HE'S NOT THE BARRY ALLEN I KNOW." Which, on the one hand, I'm always puzzled by the fact that people hate different interpretations of an established character. It's one thing if a version is inferior to the original (for example, TMNT 2012 compared to TMNT 2003 is kind of sexist, has the turtles being arrogant and not at all brotherly with each other); it's another thing if it's just different.

On the other hand, I'm kind of laughing because no one in their right minds should expect the Arrow-verse to stick closely to DC canon by now. Arrow...

- turned Green Arrow from a kind of lighthearted Batman to a super-serious, very Batman-esque hero with PTSD and a tortured past.
- did not have Dinah Laurel Lance become the Black Canary; instead, her sister is, and Arrow!Black Canary is also an ex-League of Assassins assassin, oh, and she also has PTSD now and is kind of a Broken Bird (no pun intended). And, Black Canary uses a sonic-pulse-emitting iPod instead of having her "Canary Scream."
- Dinah Laurel Lance's mother wasn't ever the Black Canary, either.
- gave Roy Harper a completely different backstory from his comic one (he has no archery training in Arrow).
- has "Speedy" who is Oliver's sister instead of Roy's nickname.
- has a daughter of Ra's al-Ghul who isn't Talia al-Ghul.
- changed Huntress from seeking vengeance for her family's murder to seeking vengeance on her father for her fiancé's murder. And she dated Oliver for a little bit and Oliver was the one who designed her costume. (Blegh.)

And, you know, this is far from an exhaustive list.

Although Arrow-verse's tendency to "rework" DC canon has made it really surprising when episode 2x08 revealed that...


...apparently Barry's mother was killed by Reverse-Flash, just like in the pre-New 52 comics. Yes, I am legitimately shocked that they kept this bit in, since I thought they would've gone for a more "realistic" route. I wonder whether they're keeping the idea from the comics that Reverse-Flash actually traveled back in time to kill Barry's mom and frame his dad, since this seems pretty random for this to just be a random crime. But that would bring all sorts of icky implications...


To get back to the original topic, I can't wait for next week's episode and I'm dying to see the Flash TV series. Speaking of which, the rumor going around is that the Iris West to Grant Gustin's Barry Allen is going to be cast as African-American, which, if true—AMAZING! And all the more reason to watch the hell out of that show when it airs!

Of course...the rumor was immediately met by racist comments like "Why are they making her black?", but oddly, the most vitriolic reactions were "Oh no that means Wally West is going to be black OH THE HORROR" and "Oh no that means Bart Allen is going to be black and so are the Tornado Twins OH THE HORROR!" (I mean, chances of Wally or Bart appearing in the new series are pretty slim at this point anyways. If Wally is even mentioned as being alive as Iris's nephew, he's sure as hell not going to become Kid Flash unless Iris's older sibling is much older than her. And the Arrow-verse might be starting to introduce the idea of superpowers, but I find it really unlikely that they're going to make the jump to time travel.)

More weird is the fact that a bunch of people seem to be taking issue with the fact that Iris is described as a psychology grad student instead of a reporter. (1) She could become a reporter when she graduates; there's such a thing called changing career ideas. (2) People say having her be a psychologist is cliché...but how exactly is this cliché? I can't recall a single major superhero's love interest who is a psychologist.

The only thing that bothers me is that her dad is now "Detective West," and I'm worried it'll repeat Green Arrow & Detective Lance's relationship, or even Spider-Man & Officer Stacy's relationship from The Amazing Spider-Man. Having the male superhero's love interest's dad be a police officer isn't exactly original by this point.

Otherwise, I'm so stoked for the Flash TV series, and I'm going to watch Barry Allen 20 more times now.
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
Can't wait for this episode! I saw the first clips today, and Arrow's Barry Allen is so freaking adorkable. He's like, a slightly chattier/more enthusiastic version of comic!Barry Allen, which I guess makes sense since they're making it really clear that he's Younger and Hipper in Arrow.
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
So the guy playing Barry Allen on Arrow is really cute. I know Barry is usually portrayed a bit older, but I guess I can't complain if The CW wants a young, hip Barry Allen (the actor's only one year older than me o_O).

Yesterday I read the issues from The Flash: Brightest Day/Road to Flashpoint, a.k.a. the Flash issues right before the New 52 reboot. And now I can finally articulate why I've found New 52 Flash to be meh from a writing standpoint (it's stellar from an art standpoint—so stellar that I am gladly following Manapul and Buccatello to Detective Comics next spring).

According to the writing in Brightest Day, Barry Allen's life stopped when his mother was murdered and he became obsessed with solving her case...until he became The Flash and started to look forward to the future again. That's a good setup for character development, right? But in the New 52, that's not really the case. I mean, yeah, they say he's obsessed with his mom's murder in issue #0 and again at the end of issue #24, but other than that he seems pretty well-adjusted. He has a girlfriend for crying out loud. And that's kind of the problem with New 52 Flash: I love him, he's a super nice guy, but his character doesn't have that much room to grow. So far his issues/arcs have been more about other characters rather than about him.

I also dislike how the emphasis in New 52 Flash is on his struggle to prove his father's innocence. DC comics are already filled with superheroes who are much more influenced by their fathers than their mothers; it would've been nice to have the Flash be different for a change. But not anymore. Sigh.
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
Arrow is going to introduce Barry Allen!!

And then the CW is going to make a Flash TV show!!!

...

...Should I be excited or afraid?

So, okay. I've already documented my distaste for The CW's Arrow, meaning I don't trust the same creators to write a good Flash TV show. Yes, apparently they said Flash wouldn't be as "dark" and "gritty" as Arrow (that's a huge relief). But besides the fact that all the angst and grimdarkness in Arrow has been so over the top that it's becoming painful to watch, there's also Arrow's iffy record when it comes to writing female characters well (*cough* HUNTRESS WHAT HAVE THEY DONE TO YOU *cough*) and the fact that I dropped the first season not because of the angst, not because of the plot clichés, and not even because of the female characters, but because I was bored.

(Also, Arrow plays really fast and loose with the source material, which isn't to say that any changes to the canon suck, but it's pretty distracting to have a character named Dinah Laurel Lance and NOT have her be the Black Canary, and it's also really distracting to build up all this "romantic tension" about will Oliver Queen and Dinah Laurel Lance get together or won't they, when they're a canon couple in the comics.)

What I'll give Arrow is that it's pretty good with secondary characters. Felicity and Diggle are fantastic. But Diggle aside, Arrow kind of has a bit of a problem with whitewashing (Sin was supposed to be East Asian...).

I don't know. I liked Arrow in the beginning. It's very clear they were taking a leaf out of Batman Begins's book, which wasn't necessarily a bad thing because it was entertaining and intriguing. But the whole "what happened to Oliver Queen on the island" subplot has been dragged out for waaay too long. The grimdarkness, as I said, is over the top; not everyone needs to have PTSD in order to become a superhero. Also, they began with a realistic depiction of Oliver's PTSD and then sort of...dropped it. Not cool. And finally, bizarrely, for a show that's trying to be about whether vigilanteism is heroic, Oliver is a giant douchebag and a hypocrite. He kills people, but criticizes his enemies for killing people and claiming he's above them. AND HE'S NEVER ONCE CALLED OUT ON THIS.

(He's also a pretty big hypocrite when it comes to demanding that other people reveal their secrets.)

But enough about Green Arrow.

So, Flash.

I can't help but be excited. Hell, I'm excited any time we get a movie/TV show that isn't about Batman or Superman, because as much as I love Batman, it's getting stale to have nothing but Batman all the time. I'm also thrilled because I really like the Flash; his powers are super cool, and it's great to have another superhero who isn't brooding and angsty all the time. And instead of being a billionaire, Barry Allen is a regular guy, a forensic scientist in fact, which means there will be lots of cool opportunities to feature crime procedurals from a scientific angle (woot!). I'm not super familiar with the Flash comics, but I'm psyched to see Iris West (and I'd love to see Wally West in the future as well!).

But it's just bizarre in general that DC is sitting on so many comic properties and yet all we get on a screen is Batman and Superman, over and over again. (I hear a Flash movie is still in development?) And, you know, even when DC branches out into non-Batman/Superman superheroes, they're always still white men. Why not a Huntress movie/TV series? Or Birds of Prey? Or any of the Batgirls (which reminds me, I also want to see Nightwing and Red Robin sometime)?

Sigh. WTF, DC. WTF.
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
Watched an episode of Arrow's Season 2 (after quitting partway through Season 1) just to see Black Canary, because Black Canary is the best, and I'm thrilled to finally see her in the show.

Kind of.

** SPOILERS BELOW **

Okay, so...Black Canary in Arrow seems to be an ex-League of Assassins, um, assassin, and is now a violent vigilante in Starling City like Oliver Queen. Apparently she's supposed to go back to the League of Assassins, but she doesn't want to. And seriously, I just don't like this direction at all to take Black Canary's character (even though we know this Black Canary isn't permanent because Dinah Laurel Lance has to eventually take the job). It just seems way too grimdark and angsty for a character who, in the comics, is usually pretty well-adjusted.

Let me add that I also really hated how Laurel was Damsel in Distress'ed AGAIN in episode 2x03, in a pretty horrifying way that was clearly intended to give her dad manpain.

I know Arrow is supposed to be a "realistic" take on superheroes in the vein of The Dark Knight, but I've always felt like that "realism" is pretty arbitrary. For example, Oliver Queen can shoot arrows with perfect aim in near-darkness? (I don't care if his vision is perfectly 20/20, there's a reason night vision goggles were invented, and that's because human beings have terrible night vision.) And his disguise is a hood and a line of green paint across his eyes? Uhh...sure...not like hoods ever fall off or anything when you're running. I'll admit that I've always thought the domino masks commonly used by most superheroes seem to be kind of flimsy disguises, but at least they're better than green paint across your eyes. And Black Canary's "Canary Scream" has been changed to a remote device that emits sonic impulses. Okay...but does Black Canary herself have earplugs to prevent her own eardrums from being ruptured? I mean, this was also a question in the comics, but there's a bit more leeway there since she had a superpower; when you try to make things "dark" and "gritty" and "ultrarealistic," you don't have that excuse.

Also, I'm still uncomfortable with the way Oliver Queen is presented as a hero. He views any other vigilante as a threat...despite the fact that they're usually only marginally more violent than he is. I mean, maybe he stopped killing random guards in Season 2 (I think), but he still interrogates people for information in really violent ways.
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
So yeah, I realized that I stopped blogging about Arrow recently. It's partly because I took a one-month hiatus from the show after the pretty underwhelming Ep. 6, and partly because there have been fewer things to talk about.

Episodes 6 through 8 have been rather dull (I wasn't a fan of the Huntress sideplot). The plot has started to pick back up again, but unfortunately Arrow isn't one of those shows you can watch out of order without missing out on some stuff related to the overarching plot (and the Wikipedia entries aren't detailed enough, dammit). Mostly, I've started to tire of the somewhat soap-opera-esque family/friend drama in the show. Almost every episode has one of Oliver's family members/friends criticizing the living daylights out of him because of his double life/inability to open up, and then later on the person apologizes...only for the pattern to repeat in the next episode. Gah.

On a more positive note, treatment of female characters has improved a lot lately, except for that cringe-worthy Helena Bertinelli subplot. I didn't like that Helena's backstory was changed from the comics, from seeking revenge for the death of her family to seeking revenge for the death of her fiancé. Oliver Queen has this chauvinistic attitude that he's able to "save" her, but then gives up because she's "beyond" saving. Hell, he even designs her signature Huntress costume for her, which was too much for me, and they break up solely because of Helena's continued angst over her fiancé's death.

So yeah, that's Arrow.
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
This episode was actually pretty good, cheesy romantic drama aside. (Did the show forget that Laurel is supposed to be dating Tommy? Because I haven't seen them together since they decided they should actually be a couple.)

So Oliver planned everything out ahead of time. Okay. We also get more answers about what happened to Oliver on the island and the source of his PTSD. Cool. And Moira has suddenly become a far more complicated character than we thought. Because of a previous episode, I thought she intentionally had her husband and son killed off, but now it seems as though that wasn't her decision; rather, she's working for someone else. But the questions remain: Who is she working for? Why did they need to sabotage the yacht? Was Moira down with this, and why? And we still don't know why the yacht's been salvaged.

I didn't like the fact that Laurel's mom is revealed to have run away after Laurel's sister's death. (Her mom is supposed to be the original Black Canary sobsob)

Aside from Moira and Laurel, female characters didn't really have any major roles in this episode.
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
I have mixed feelings about this episode.

On the female characters front

At first, it looked like Laurel was becoming more awesome by partnering up with Green Arrow to save the innocent, but then she's almost strangled to death, Green Arrow has to save her (what happened to her self-defense skills, again?), and she cuts ties with him because he almost killed her attacker.

Look, I believe in the sanctity of the law. I also think murder is a horrible thing. But shouldn't she at least be glad that he freaking saved her life? Instead, her first reaction is, "Oh no my savior's a killer looks like I should stay away from him."

The scene in which Laurel's life was threatened made me extremely uncomfortable, not only because it plays up the Damsel in Distress card, but also because the way the violence was shown made me terrified that it was going to be an attempted rape. It ended up not being that, which is a relief, but still.

Her law firm friend, Joanna, is completely shallow. Every time Laurel is busy working on a case, Joanna's just like, "Stop working so hard so you can go to parties and get a boyfriend!" Because clearly devotion to your career isn't as important as getting laid. Ugh. (Also, I thought Laurel was dating Tommy??)

In sum: The show continues not to impress in its treatment of women. Although, for once, Thea actually acted nicely toward her brother (but this is right after he'd been chewed out by Laurel, and it's a bit of Mood Whiplash from Thea's previous attitude towards him). Also, one bright point (so far) is Felicity Smoaks, who looks to be an awesome character. Let's hope the show doesn't ruin her as well.

On the moral ambiguity front

I was surprised that Arrow actually began to touch on Oliver's darker side, because that's more than I was expecting. People are beginning to call him out for the ease with which he kills people. This is interesting, although I still wonder how far they'll actually go with this. If they're going to address death, I feel that they should've made a fuss about Green Arrow's killing of random security guards in pursuit of his targets (hey, security guards are getting paid for what they do, people), not his almost-killing of someone who tried to kill an innocent bystander. (Or, to put it in TV Troperish, addressing What Measure Is a Mook? is a more effective angle than saying What the Hell, Hero? for kicking around an Asshole Victim.)

Other Thoughts

Green Arrow said something this episode that really made me think of Batman/The Dark Knight--about how he needed to wear the hood in order to protect the people he loved.

For all its flaws, Arrow does have a writer who knows how to dish up suspense in spades. We end with Laurel's dad figuring out Oliver is Green Arrow and arresting him (which is...pretty early on in the season for that device to be used) and Walter finding the remains of the Queens' sunken yacht in a mysterious warehouse set up by Moira Queen, passworded by the name of her dead husband. Whaa?
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
I stand corrected: apparently Oliver's superhero outfit is bulletproof. Which is why he willingly goes into battle with guys with machine guns. Still, how much of his body does this bulletproof armor cover? This episode shows it doesn't cover his arms, so does it cover his legs? His head?? All it would take is one bullet to put Oliver out of commission, so it still looks to me like he has super dodging skills. (Also, I haven't done any research into bulletproof wear, but while Oliver may not die if he gets a bullet to the torso, the force of impact should at least knock him down. So far, this has only happened once, in the pilot episode.)

Now, Episode 3. (Or, "In Which Oliver Queen Does Assassin's Creed-Style Parkour")

So I think we're actually starting to see some improvement here in terms of female characters. Laurel finally actually kicks some ass! And there's a mother-daughter bonding moment between Thea and Moira Queen! Of course, that doesn't negate the fact that Thea is a shoplifting, drug- and alcohol-using troubled little sis and Moira, for all we know, is still evil. And Thea is continuing to be mean to Oliver and throw hissy fits whenever he tries to actually be a responsible big brother. Sigh.

But THAT ENDING. If there's one thing Arrow knows how to do so far, it's how to write a cliffhanger ending.

I actually like this episode quite a bit. Not too much happens, because it's all about Oliver trying to find and eliminate Deadshot, but the execution is not too bad.

Tommy has been a really good friend to Oliver so far. I shudder to think about how he'll eventually wind up as Green Arrow's archnemesis, Merlyn.

It's interesting to compare Arrow to Batman Begins, as the stories are, in certain ways, very similar (wealthy billionaire returns home after a prolonged absence to fight crime), and yet there are a couple of key differences: In Arrow, Oliver Queen returns home with a vendetta and isn't actually above killing people to fulfill his goals, although he usually tries to give his target a chance to repent (I feel bad for all the security guards who get shot, though). Bruce Wayne, on the other hand, is anti-injustice in general and very much against killing. I'm very curious as to whether people (who find out about Oliver's identity) will eventually call him out for the violence he's causing. Certainly Detective Lance is, but so far I feel that he's there in the story more as an obstacle rather than a moral objection to vigilante violence. If the show does explore the implications of vigilante violence, that would elevate it to one of the more nuanced, thoughtful, intelligent TV shows out there. But I mustn't get my hopes up, for that way disappointment lies...

I had an interesting thought while watching this episode: What if, instead of Laurel's dad being the detective/cop, it was her mom? Wouldn't that make the story so much more interesting?
rainwaterspark: Image of Jim Hawkins solar surfing from Disney's Treasure Planet (treasure planet jim hawkins solar surfin)
I've never done this before--usually I just blog about TV shows if there's a particular episode that makes me ragey or exhilarated--but I decided to start doing a "Let's Watch"/impressions/critical analysis of The CW's new show, Arrow. In short, it's an origin story about the comic book superhero Oliver Queen, a.k.a. Green Arrow, with a "darker and grittier" atmosphere à la Christopher Nolan's Batman Begins.

Full disclosure: I knew nothing about the original Green Arrow before watching the show. I did Wikipedia some information after watching the pilot, though.


Episode 1 )



Episode 2 )

Profile

rainwaterspark: Moon Knight from Moon Knight (2021) title page, drawn by Alessandro Cappuccio (Default)
rainwaterspark

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 25th, 2025 12:21 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios